Photo: MBC News
Smiths Falls’ century-old water tower is set to come down after town council approved a $356,160 demolition contract, despite concerns from some councillors about whether enough has been done to assess the structure.
The November 9th decision followed debate over whether another structural assessment should be completed before demolition.
Councillors Jennifer Miller and Christopher McGuire argued the town should spend between $5,000 and $30,000 on additional engineering work to determine whether the tower could be preserved, not as an operating water tower, but as a historical landmark.
McGuire argued existing engineering reports examined the tower as a functioning water tower rather than as a standalone structure and heritage landmark, and the town should follow their Heritage Conservation District policy.
McGuire said the town’s Heritage Conservation District plan allows demolition in exceptional circumstances, including structural instability.
Other councillors supported moving ahead, pointing to the tower’s age and previous engineering reports documenting significant deterioration.
Councillor Peter McKenna said he doesn’t have joy in his heart to see the tower be demolished, but doesn’t see the financial sense in pursuing additional work.
The demolition is expected to be completed before Christmas.